Beach House

Paraty beach house

Beach House in Paraty, Brazil, by Marcio Kogan

A spectacular beach house, designed by architect Marcio Kogan, is an apparent structural ingenuity. The house looks like something out of a James Bond movie, but underneath the shiny surface, everything is not so pretty…

There is alegend that says that the region of the colonial town ofParaty, situated on the Brazilian coast just south of Rio de Janeiro, has 365 islands, one for every day of the year.Two apparent concrete boxes lie embedded in the side of one of these islands. Their volumes protrude out of the mountain, almost on beach level,with a cantilever of up to 8 meters, forming a habitable space inthe middle of nature.






So much for the pretty exterior, but there is more: The house was constructed in a natural reserve, and Brazilian Justice ordered it’s demolition in 2010, just months after it’s conclusion, because of breaching ambiental laws. The owners, however, did not bow for Justice. The house is still standing. We might note that the owners are quite powerful:

The beachhouse in Paraty is owned by the Marinho family, the founders of Rede Globo. a television network that was launched in 1965, right after the military coup in Brazil. The company thrived under the military regime and until this day could be considered the fourth power in the nation; also one of the largest media companies in the world. Through its network, the broadcaster covers 98.6% of Brazil’s territory. For many people living in less densely populated areas, Globo is their only source of information. No democratic country has a media network with so much influence over it’s citizens. Globo influences elections and colors their news broadcasts from a rightwing, conservative perspective.

The Marinho family position themselves above the law, a bit like Brazilian royalty, which leads to irritation in less conservative circles. In Paraty, the Marinhos not only constructed the house and an adjacent heliport in a natural reserve, but also claim the beach in front of it as their own. One should know that By Brazilian law, all beaches are public; private beaches are not allowed. This weekend there were protests in front of the house by a group of activists that calls itself Midia Ninja. They “invaded” the beach in front of the house, thus claiming it as public territory:

Paraty Globo protests

Activists of Midia Ninja in front of the house.

Instead of apologizing for their collaboration in the coup of 64, Globo warned that they are already plotting another. But times have changed and we are no longer the same. We know that their empire was built during the military dictatorship with resources that belong to the Brazilian society. All that belongs to Globo is ours. We will invade your beach!” the activists stated.

They have a point:  But illegal as it may be, the house does possess certain architectural qualities. Demolishing it would be a pity. Considering that it was built in a public space (the beach) and payed for with (historically) public money, it should be public. Instead of demolishing the beachhouse, it might be turned it into a public pavillion, not unlike the French did to their royal properties back in 1789.

















Markthal Rotterdam

Markthal Rotterdam. Photo:RM

De toonaangevende reisgids Lonely Planet heeft Rotterdam verkozen tot nummer vijf in de top tien van ‘topsteden van de wereld’. Het is de enige Nederlandse stad in de lijst van Lonely Planet’s Best in Travel 2016. De vorig jaar opgeleverde Markthal speelt hierin waarschijnlijk een rol. Een bijzonder gebouw met een wat misleidende naam, omdat het  op een aantal punten wezenlijk verschilt van wat normaal gesproken als markthal wordt beschouwd:  Continue reading

Less is Less, More is More

“Less is More”, a famous German architect once said. Nonsense, of course; Less is just less.

Dean Gardens Estate in Atlanta: More is definitely more.

Dean Gardens Estate in Atlanta: More is definitely more.

With an area of over 3500 m2, Dean Gardens Estate was, at the time of its completion in 1992, the largest residence in Atlanta. The owner, software tycoon Larry Dean, put it back on sale again just two years later. Finally, after17 years it sold for $ 7 million, a fraction of the original construction costs. Why? Continue reading

Revelation through Concealment

veiled building

Veiled building. Photo: RM

In phases of transition, such as renovation or (partial) demolition, buildings sometimes show themselves in a new and unexpected way. By removing layers of the facade buildings often gain a more interesting appearance, a stronger expressiveness. When a building is halfway demolished, you often get a kind of reversal, if it were pulled inside out. The underlying structure becomes visible, inner walls become facades. Continue reading

The New Forbidden City

CCTV fence

CCTV Tower that burned in 2009. Photo: RM

The Forbidden City was built in the 15th century, after the capital of the Chinese empire was moved from Nanjing (literally translated: “southern capital”) to Beijing (the “Northern Capital”). It was the place from which the Chinese emperors of the Ming and the Qing Dynasties ruled over China. Hidden behind 10 high meter walls, hermetically closed for the people of China, who could only imagine what took place inside these walls. Only in 1925, after the fall of the monarchy and the departure of the last emperor, the Forbidden City was first opened to the public. Continue reading

A Tale of the Tub

De Kuip as an icon

From L to R: De Kuip at its opening in 1937; De Kuip Icon; IS in action.

Our monuments, the icons of our civilization, are of great value to us and should, in priciple, be preserved. In principle, because sometimes the fear to discard our (built) icons comes to stand in the way of our progress. In this post a first example of this phenomenon: The Feyenoord Stadium in Rotterdam. Continue reading

The Bilbao Effect

architecture blog, Bilbao effect

L:Theater de Stoep, R: Supercoop supermarket, Spijkenisse, photos: RM

Take an unattractive city. Through an appealing, or at least eye-catching building designed by a famous architect, it can be pulled out of the doldrums. The Bilbao effect is named after the city of Bilbao where the Frank Gehry-designed Guggenheim Museum designed by Frank Gehry accomplished this feat. It’s example was followed by many, think of EYE in Amsterdam North, but its initial success could never quite be equalled. Continue reading